The short answer
Use canonical signals for equivalent versions and noindex when the page should be excluded from search.

A three-step workflow
Define the intended outcome
Write down whether you want an equivalent version consolidated or the page excluded from search. These are different objectives.
Compare content equivalence
Compare the content and purpose of the URLs. A page with a distinct user task may not be a true duplicate.
Check conflicting signals
Check redirects, canonicals and indexing directives together. Avoid conflicting controls and validate the chosen behavior on representative URLs.
Illustrative example
Put the decision in context
A tracking-parameter copy may point to the clean canonical URL. A private internal results page may require a different exclusion strategy.
What to record in your working sheet
Keep the evidence beside the decision so the work can be checked and handed over. For this task, use these fields:
- Affected URL and expected behavior
- Observed response and page directive
- Conflicting signal or supporting evidence
- Proposed fix, owner and retest result
A mistake to avoid
Using noindex as a substitute for canonical consolidation.
References and further reading
The workflow and illustrative example are SEOByIndia editorial guidance. Use the linked primary documentation for platform requirements; interfaces and policies can change.
Need help applying this to your site?
Share your website, the problem you are investigating and the evidence you already have. We can discuss a focused scope and the next useful check.
Discuss a technical SEO audit