The short answer
Compare intent, usefulness and overlap before choosing an update, consolidation or removal plan.

A three-step workflow
Inventory overlapping URLs
Create an inventory of the overlapping pages, their intended task and any useful evidence or links each contains.
Compare distinct value
Compare what a reader gains from each page. Age or traffic alone does not establish whether content should be consolidated.
Choose a documented action
Document the chosen destination and handling for retired URLs. Preserve distinct useful material and verify important links after changes.
Illustrative example
Put the decision in context
Two posts answer the same audit question with outdated steps. Combine the strongest material into the most appropriate destination and plan relevant redirects.
What to record in your working sheet
Keep the evidence beside the decision so the work can be checked and handed over. For this task, use these fields:
- Article URL and reader task
- Claim or section requiring work
- Source and proposed editorial change
- Reviewer, completion check and actual update date
A mistake to avoid
Deleting useful pages because they are old.
References and further reading
The workflow and illustrative example are SEOByIndia editorial guidance. Use the linked primary documentation for platform requirements; interfaces and policies can change.
Need help applying this to your site?
Share your website, the problem you are investigating and the evidence you already have. We can discuss a focused scope and the next useful check.
Discuss an editorial content review